By Ken Y-N (
January 31, 2008 at 22:20)
· Filed under Polls, Society
With the biggest stories in Japan this week being pesticide poisoning from Chinese gyoza, which is looking like a deliberate case of tampering with the packaging line, according to an expert on NHK news tonight, this recent survey from MyVoice on the image of Chinese products is most timely, although given the figures here China’s image can hardly sink any lower.
Demographics
Over the first five days of January 2008 12,669 members of the MyVoice internet community successfully completed a private internet-based questionnaire. 54% of the sample was female, 2% in their teens, 15% in their twenties, 38% in their thirties, 29% in their forties, and 16% in their fifties.
I personally try to avoid as much Chinese foodstuffs as possible. One problem, though, especially for prepared foods, is that although the preparation might happen in Japan thus meriting a Made in Japan label, the ingredients may be imported. For instance, I have heard that some brands of instant noodles use cabbages from China. I saw a program on food safety in the Chinese domestic market, and if that is anything to base tourism decisions on, if you are going to the Beijing Olympics, you would be best advised to bring your own food and make sure your travel insurance is up to date!
On the other hand, I do a lot of shopping at the 100 yen shop, and the vast majority of their brands are made in China, but a laundry net or a calendar is hardly going to kill you! It is also pretty difficult to avoid Made in China clothes, as retailers from UniQlo to Aeon use the country as their primary source.
Research results
Q1: Do you feel worried about or aversion to using Chinese products? (Sample size=12,669)
| |
Now, Jan 2008 |
Oct 2005 |
| Yes |
88.2% |
50.4% |
| No |
11.8% |
49.6% |
Q2: How has your image of Chinese products changed? (Sample size=12,669)
| Become better than before |
2.5% |
| No particular change |
21.8% |
| Become worse than before |
75.7% |
One might presume that within the “no particular change” group there must be some people whose answer meant “it couldn’t get any worse”!
Q3: Which of the following categories of Chinese products have you purchased? (Sample size=12,669, multiple answer)
| Clothes |
71.0% |
| Processed foods |
53.1% |
| Vegetables |
52.2% |
| Shoes, bag |
49.1% |
| Household items |
44.4% |
| Tea |
41.7% |
| Meat, fish |
40.2% |
| Electrical products |
28.7% |
| Beverages, alcohol |
22.8% |
| Pottery, ceramics |
18.9% |
| Watch, glasses, accessories |
18.7% |
| Furniture, bedding, interior |
18.4% |
| Computer items |
14.5% |
| Beauty, health, cosmetics |
9.1% |
| Medical items, drugs |
5.1% |
| Movie, DVD |
4.3% |
| Music |
3.6% |
| Car |
1.0% |
| Other |
6.7% |
| Don’t know |
10.1% |
| Never bought any Chinese goods |
1.4% |
| No answer |
0.1% |
Q4: From the following categories of foodstuffs, medical items, and other items that directly affect one’s body, which China-made products would you not want to purchase? (Sample size=12,669, multiple answer)
| Meat, fish |
87.1% |
| Vegetables |
84.1% |
| Processed foods |
80.9% |
| Medical items, drugs |
74.0% |
| Beauty, health, cosmetics |
65.5% |
| Beverages, alcohol |
60.7% |
| Tea |
56.7% |
| Other |
18.0% |
| None in particular |
4.1% |
| No answer |
0.2% |
Q5: Why would you not want to purchase the items from Q4? (Sample size=12,669, multiple answer)
| Poor safety |
90.8% |
| Untrustworthy |
73.2% |
| Poor quality |
54.4% |
| Not technically advanced |
23.2% |
| Break easily, not long-lasting |
19.5% |
| Poor aesthetics |
8.1% |
| Unoriginal |
5.9% |
| Expensive |
0.6% |
| Other |
3.7% |
| Nothing in particular |
0.2% |
| No answer |
0.2% |
Q6: From the following categories of items, which China-made products would you not want to purchase? (Sample size=12,669, multiple answer)
| Electrical products |
56.5% |
| Computer items |
53.1% |
| Car |
52.5% |
| Watch, glasses, accessories |
36.2% |
| Movie, DVD |
33.0% |
| Music |
31.3% |
| Shoes, bag |
30.1% |
| Furniture, bedding, interior |
28.4% |
| Clothes |
27.5% |
| Household items |
24.7% |
| Pottery, ceramics |
24.4% |
| Other |
10.7% |
| Nothing in particular |
16.3% |
| No answer |
0.2% |
Q7: Why would you not want to purchase the items from Q6? (Sample size=12,669, multiple answer)
| Untrustworthy |
69.7% |
| Poor safety |
62.2% |
| Break easily, not long-lasting |
52.3% |
| Poor quality |
52.3% |
| Not technically advanced |
46.6% |
| Poor aesthetics |
17.5% |
| Unoriginal |
12.8% |
| Expensive |
2.4% |
| Other |
5.3% |
| Nothing in particular |
0.4% |
| No answer |
0.2% |
If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed, or check out my weekly newsletter. Thanks for visiting!
Read more on: china,
myvoice
Permalink
Related articles:
Food safety worries five in six JapaneseNine in ten apprehensive purchasing Chinese foodsJapan, Korea and China look at each otherReminder: What Japan Thinks Newsletter, and a new web site
Janne said,
January 31, 2008 @ 23:32
To be fair, Japanese food manufacturers have not exactly covered themselves in glory the past year or so. I rather suspect that the only difference between Japanese and Chinese producers is how good they are at covering things up.
And for Japanese manufacturers it seems to hit the high-end as much or more; I saw a report that mentioned that if all chicken being sold as premium Jidori was true, there would have to be more than ten times the actual number.
Ken Y-N said,
January 31, 2008 @ 23:43
Yes, I suppose one can argue that there is the distraction factor in this news to take away from last year being the Year of the Fake, but this story seems to be developing into one suggesting maliciousness behind the poisoning.
www.japansoc.com said,
January 31, 2008 @ 23:47
Japanese views on Chinese products from foodstuffs to electronics…
What do the Japanese think of Chinese-made items? A timely and relevant survey given the recent gyoza kerfuffle….
ShaneS said,
February 1, 2008 @ 04:42
Thanks for posting this survey - it very interesting and timely. While I understand that it may be difficult to determine where something originates from by its made in designation I am curious to know what the Kanji would be for “Made in China”? As a foreigner who can barely speak Japanese let alone read Kanji this would be very helpful to know. I tired to search via various online dictionaries and came up confused…
I am with you on the 100 Yen store products for the home food or other times that you put in your body is a whole different matter. Thanks.
Ken Y-N said,
February 1, 2008 @ 08:38
ShaneS: the offical phrase for mainland China is 中華人民共和国, I think, although sometimes it is abbreviated to just 中国.
ShaneS said,
February 1, 2008 @ 09:18
Thanks Ken! I may copy this and put it in my wallet. I’m going to tell everyone about this over at JapanSoc!
Japanese Thoughts on Chinese Products said,
February 1, 2008 @ 11:11
[…] has heard about the pesticide poisoning from Chinese gyoza in Japan. And just at the right time, whatjapanthinks found a nice survey from Myvoice surveying how japanese view Chinese […]
Japan Talk #095 said,
February 3, 2008 @ 06:06
[…] * What Japan Thinks (About Chinese Products) […]
Fan Li said,
February 16, 2008 @ 13:19
I am chinese. japanese products are much better in quality. I hope China enforce stricter laws on quality control. But I have to say that I eat chinese food all the time, some produced in US, some imported from China, I never had problem. After all, I can never stay away from chinese food,
hope I won’t be the next victim
Food safety worries five in six Japanese » 世論 What Japan Thinks said,
February 16, 2008 @ 23:08
[…] to see, but goo Research sadly only reported three questions. An earlier survey from MyVoice on Chinese products provides a useful […]